History of the Cobble Hill
- Origin
- New York, USA
- Created
- 2000s
- Creator
- Sam Ross
- Family
- Brooklyn variation
Sam Ross created the Cobble Hill at Milk & Honey in New York, adding to the family of Brooklyn variations named after the borough's neighbourhoods.
It is unusual for a stirred whiskey drink because it includes fresh cucumber. Muddled into the mixing glass with rye, dry vermouth and Amaro Montenegro, it gives a cool, green freshness.
How to Get It Right
- Muddle the cucumber gently in the mixing glass first.
- Stir with ice and fine strain to catch the cucumber pieces.
- Garnish with a thin cucumber slice.
Variations
| Variation | What changes |
|---|---|
| Bensonhurst | Maraschino and Cynar |
| Brooklyn | The original, with Amer Picon |
| Little Italy | Sweet vermouth and Cynar |
Cobble Hill FAQ
What is in a Cobble Hill?
Rye whiskey, dry vermouth, Amaro Montenegro and cucumber.
Why cucumber in a stirred drink?
It adds a fresh, green note that lifts the whiskey.
What can I use instead of Amaro Montenegro?
Another light, floral amaro such as Amaro Nonino.
What glass is a Cobble Hill served in?
A coupe. The stem keeps your hand away from the cold drink, and the curved rim makes it far harder to spill than a V-shaped martini glass.
Is a Cobble Hill shaken or stirred?
Stirred. It contains only spirits and modifiers, so stirring chills and dilutes it while keeping it clear and silky.
How strong is a Cobble Hill?
About 24% ABV after dilution, or roughly 2 US standard drinks (29 g of alcohol) per serve.
How many calories are in a Cobble Hill?
Roughly 226 kcal per drink, most of it from alcohol.
Can I make a Cobble Hill without rye whiskey?
Yes. Bourbon is the closest substitute, though the drink will taste different.









