History of the Bensonhurst
- Origin
- New York, USA
- Created
- Mid-2000s
- Creator
- Chad Solomon
- Family
- Brooklyn variation
The Brooklyn is a pre-Prohibition rye cocktail with dry vermouth, maraschino and Amer Picon. In the 2000s New York bartenders made a game of riffing on it and naming each version after a Brooklyn neighbourhood.
Chad Solomon created the Bensonhurst at Pegu Club, named after a historically Italian-American neighbourhood. Italian Cynar replaces the hard-to-find Amer Picon.
How to Get It Right
- Use a 50% ABV rye such as a bottled-in-bond.
- Measure the Cynar carefully. A bar spoon is enough.
- Stir until very cold and serve straight up.
Variations
| Variation | What changes |
|---|---|
| Brooklyn | Amer Picon instead of Cynar |
| Red Hook | Punt e Mes instead of dry vermouth |
| Greenpoint | Yellow Chartreuse and sweet vermouth |
| Cobble Hill | Amaro Montenegro and cucumber |
Bensonhurst FAQ
What is in a Bensonhurst?
Rye whiskey, dry vermouth, maraschino liqueur and Cynar.
Why is it named Bensonhurst?
It is one of many Brooklyn variations named after the borough's neighbourhoods.
Is it bitter?
Only lightly. The Cynar adds a gentle bittersweet note.
What glass is a Bensonhurst served in?
A coupe. The stem keeps your hand away from the cold drink, and the curved rim makes it far harder to spill than a V-shaped martini glass.
Is a Bensonhurst shaken or stirred?
Stirred. It contains only spirits and modifiers, so stirring chills and dilutes it while keeping it clear and silky.
How strong is a Bensonhurst?
About 24% ABV after dilution, or roughly 2 US standard drinks (28 g of alcohol) per serve.
How many calories are in a Bensonhurst?
Roughly 215 kcal per drink, most of it from alcohol.
Can I make a Bensonhurst without rye whiskey?
Yes. Bourbon is the closest substitute, though the drink will taste different.









