Skip to content
Printable Pour GuideCocktail Menu MakerSpin the BottleFree Pour CameraTilt PourCount-Pour TrainerMy BarBatch CalculatorOver-Pour Cost CalculatorABV and Calorie CalculatorBar Unit ConverterGlass Measuring Card
Benton's Old Fashioned Cocktail served on a black bar counter
Benton's Old Fashioned Cocktail
  1. Home
  2. Cocktails
  3. Whiskey Cocktails
  4. Benton's Old Fashioned

Benton's Old Fashioned

Bacon-fat-washed bourbon with maple syrup and Angostura. Smoky, savoury breakfast flavours in an Old Fashioned.

Strength
28% ABV
Std. drinks (US)
1.6
Calories
173 kcal
In the glass
3⅓ oz
Method
Stirred
  • Bourbon
  • Maple Syrup
  • Angostura Bitters

How to Make a Benton's Old Fashioned

  1. Fat-wash the bourbon: mix it with warm bacon fat, leave for 4 hours, freeze until the fat sets, then strain.
    Step 1 of making a Benton's Old Fashioned Cocktail: fat-wash the bourbon: mix it with warm bacon fat, leave for 4 hours, freeze until the fat sets, then strain
  2. Add the bacon bourbon, maple syrup and Angostura to a mixing glass with ice.
    Step 2 of making a Benton's Old Fashioned Cocktail: add the bacon bourbon, maple syrup and Angostura to a mixing glass with ice
  3. Stir for 30 seconds until cold.
    Step 3 of making a Benton's Old Fashioned Cocktail: stir for 30 seconds until cold
  4. Strain over a large ice cube in a rocks glass.
  5. Express an orange twist over the top.

Bartender's tip: Fat-wash a 750 ml bottle with 45 ml warm bacon fat for 4 hours, freeze until the fat sets, then strain through a coffee filter.

Taste Profile

Sweet
Sour
Bitter
Strong
Fresh

Rate and Review

No ratings yet. Tap the stars to be the first.

History of Benton's Old Fashioned

Origin
PDT, New York, United States
Created
2007
Created by
Don Lee
Family
Old Fashioned, modern classic

Don Lee created this drink at PDT (Please Don't Tell), the speakeasy hidden behind a phone booth in a hot-dog shop in New York's East Village. He used a technique called fat-washing: bourbon is mixed with warm bacon fat, left to infuse, then frozen so the fat sets and can be lifted off, leaving the spirit smoky and savoury.

The bacon came from Benton's Smoky Mountain Country Hams in Madisonville, Tennessee, famous for its intensely smoked meats. Sweetened with maple syrup, the result tastes like a Sunday breakfast in an Old Fashioned glass and made fat-washing famous around the world.

How to Get It Right

  • Fat-wash with about 45 ml of rendered bacon fat per 750 ml of bourbon.
  • Freeze for at least two hours, then strain through a coffee filter.
  • Use grade A dark maple syrup and stir well over a large cube.

Fun Facts

  • PDT has been named among the best bars in the world several times.
  • Fat-washing also works with butter, sesame oil and coconut oil.
  • Benton's hams are smoked over hickory for days.

Variations

VariationWhat changes
Old FashionedPlain bourbon and sugar
Rum Old FashionedAged rum as the base
Oaxaca Old FashionedTequila and mezcal

Benton's Old Fashioned FAQ

What is fat-washing?

Infusing a spirit with fat, then freezing it so the fat can be removed, leaving flavour and a silky texture.

Who created Benton's Old Fashioned?

Don Lee, at PDT in New York, in 2007.

Does it taste of bacon?

Gently: smoky and savoury, balanced by maple syrup.

What glass is a Benton's Old Fashioned served in?

A rocks glass. The wide mouth puts the aroma of a citrus twist right under your nose, and the heavy base survives muddling and stirring in the glass.

Is a Benton's Old Fashioned shaken or stirred?

Stirred. It contains only spirits and modifiers, so stirring chills and dilutes it while keeping it clear and silky.

How strong is a Benton's Old Fashioned?

About 28% ABV after dilution, or roughly 1.6 US standard drinks (22 g of alcohol) per serve.

How many calories are in a Benton's Old Fashioned?

Roughly 173 kcal per drink, most of it from alcohol.

Can I make a Benton's Old Fashioned without bourbon?

Yes. Rye Whiskey is the closest substitute, though the drink will taste different.

If You Like the Benton's Old Fashioned