Skip to content
Printable Pour GuideCocktail Menu MakerSpin the BottleFree Pour CameraTilt PourCount-Pour TrainerMy BarBatch CalculatorOver-Pour Cost CalculatorABV and Calorie CalculatorBar Unit ConverterGlass Measuring Card
Illegal Cocktail served on a black bar counter
Illegal Cocktail
  1. Home
  2. Cocktails
  3. Tequila and Mezcal Cocktails
  4. Illegal

Illegal

Mezcal, Jamaican overproof rum, falernum and maraschino with lime. A smoky, spicy tiki sour.

Strength
16% ABV
Std. drinks (US)
1.4
Calories
203 kcal
In the glass
5⅓ oz
Method
Shaken
  • Mezcal
  • Overproof Rum
  • Falernum
  • Maraschino Liqueur
  • Lime Juice
  • Simple Syrup

How to Make an Illegal

  1. Add the mezcal, overproof rum, falernum, maraschino liqueur, lime juice and simple syrup to a shaker.
    Step 1 of making an Illegal Cocktail: add the mezcal, overproof rum, falernum, maraschino liqueur, lime juice and simple syrup to a shaker
  2. Fill with ice and shake hard for 12 to 15 seconds.
    Step 2 of making an Illegal Cocktail: fill with ice and shake hard for 12 to 15 seconds
  3. Strain into a chilled coupe.
    Step 3 of making an Illegal Cocktail: strain into a chilled coupe
  4. Garnish with a lime wheel.

Bartender's tip: Add a few drops of egg white, as the IBA allows, for a silkier texture.

Taste Profile

Sweet
Sour
Bitter
Strong
Fresh

Rate and Review

No ratings yet. Tap the stars to be the first.

History of the Illegal

Origin
Disputed; Italian and mezcal-brand accounts
Created
2010s
Family
Sour, tiki-style
Classic status
IBA official cocktail (2020)

The Illegal shares its name with Ilegal Mezcal, the brand founded in Antigua, Guatemala, in 2006, and much of its early fame came from the brand's promotion. Its exact origin is still debated. One account credits Italian bartender Samuele Ambrosi, who reworked a tequila drink with falernum, Jamaican rum, maraschino and lime, then switched the tequila for mezcal.

What is certain is that the International Bartenders Association added the Illegal to its New Era list in 2020. Its specification is a clever balance: smoky espadín mezcal, funky Jamaican overproof rum, spiced falernum, a barspoon of maraschino and fresh lime.

How to Get It Right

  • Measure the overproof rum carefully; it is twice as strong as standard rum.
  • Use a mild espadín mezcal so the falernum and rum still show.
  • A few drops of egg white, as the IBA allows, soften the edges.
  • Serve straight up in a coupe, or on ice in a clay cup.

Fun Facts

  • The drink combines two spirits that rarely meet: mezcal and Jamaican rum.
  • It is sometimes called an Illegal Margarita, though it has no orange liqueur.
  • Falernum, from Barbados, adds lime, ginger, clove and almond.

Variations

VariationWhat changes
Nuclear DaiquiriOverproof rum with Green Chartreuse and falernum
Tia MiaRum and mezcal in a Mai Tai
Mezcal MargaritaMezcal, orange liqueur and lime

Illegal FAQ

What is in an Illegal cocktail?

Mezcal, Jamaican overproof rum, falernum, maraschino, lime and simple syrup.

Is the Illegal an IBA cocktail?

Yes, it has been on the IBA New Era list since 2020.

Is the Illegal strong?

Yes. Overproof rum makes it noticeably stronger than a Margarita.

What glass is an Illegal served in?

A coupe. The stem keeps your hand away from the cold drink, and the curved rim makes it far harder to spill than a V-shaped martini glass.

Is an Illegal shaken or stirred?

Shaken. It contains citrus, juice, cream or egg, which need the force and aeration of shaking.

How strong is an Illegal?

About 16% ABV after dilution, or roughly 1.4 US standard drinks (20 g of alcohol) per serve.

How many calories are in an Illegal?

Roughly 203 kcal per drink, most of it from alcohol and sugar.

Can I make an Illegal without mezcal?

Yes. Tequila Blanco is the closest substitute, though the drink will taste different.

If You Like the Illegal