Skip to content
Printable Pour GuideCocktail Menu MakerSpin the BottleFree Pour CameraTilt PourCount-Pour TrainerMy BarBatch CalculatorOver-Pour Cost CalculatorABV and Calorie CalculatorBar Unit ConverterGlass Measuring Card
Fish House Punch served on a black bar counter
Fish House Punch
  1. Home
  2. Cocktails
  3. Rum Cocktails
  4. Fish House Punch

Fish House Punch

Aged rum, cognac, peach and lemon: the punch of Philadelphia's oldest gentlemen's club.

Strength
13% ABV
Std. drinks (US)
1.3
Calories
191 kcal
In the glass
6 oz
Method
Stirred
  • Aged Rum
  • Cognac
  • Peach Schnapps
  • Lemon Juice
  • Simple Syrup
  • Chilled Water

How to Make a Fish House Punch

  1. Add the aged rum, cognac, peach schnapps, lemon juice, simple syrup and chilled water to a mixing glass.
    Step 1 of making a Fish House Punch: add the aged rum, cognac, peach schnapps, lemon juice, simple syrup and chilled water to a mixing glass
  2. Fill with ice and stir for 25 to 30 seconds until well chilled.
    Step 2 of making a Fish House Punch: fill with ice and stir for 25 to 30 seconds until well chilled
  3. Strain into a rocks glass over a large ice cube.
    Step 3 of making a Fish House Punch: strain into a rocks glass over a large ice cube
  4. Garnish with a lemon wheel and freshly grated nutmeg.

Bartender's tip: For a party bowl, multiply by 12, stir with a large block of ice and let it stand for an hour before serving.

Taste Profile

Sweet
Sour
Bitter
Strong
Fresh

Rate and Review

No ratings yet. Tap the stars to be the first.

History of the Fish House Punch

Origin
Schuylkill Fishing Company, Philadelphia, United States
Created
Club founded 1732
Family
Punch
Base
Rum and cognac

The Schuylkill Fishing Company was founded in 1732 on the banks of the Schuylkill River, outside Philadelphia. It is often called the oldest social club in the English-speaking world, and its members, known as citizens of "the State in Schuylkill", have made the same punch for nearly three centuries.

The recipe combines aged rum, cognac and peach brandy with lemon, sugar and water, poured over a large block of ice. A popular story says George Washington visited the club and left no diary entries for the following three days.

The Classic Bowl

For about 20 servings

750 ml aged rum, 375 ml cognac, 120 ml peach brandy.

350 ml fresh lemon juice, 250 g sugar dissolved in 1 litre of water or cold black tea.

Pour over a large block of ice and leave for an hour before serving.

How to Get It Right

  • Make an oleo saccharum by rubbing lemon peels with the sugar for extra aroma.
  • A big ice block melts slowly and dilutes the punch evenly.
  • Real peach brandy is dry; peach liqueur is sweeter, so use less sugar.

Fun Facts

  • Punch came to Britain from India in the 17th century; the word may come from the Hindi panch, five, for its five ingredients.
  • The club is still active and still makes its punch.
  • Fish House Punch is famously easy to drink and famously strong.

Variations

VariationWhat changes
Planter's PunchDark rum, grenadine and bitters
Rum PunchCaribbean rum with fruit juices
Pisco PunchPisco and pineapple

Fish House Punch FAQ

What is in Fish House Punch?

Aged rum, cognac, peach brandy, lemon, sugar and water.

How old is Fish House Punch?

It comes from a Philadelphia club founded in 1732.

Is Fish House Punch strong?

Yes. It tastes light but contains a lot of spirit, so serve small cups.

What glass is a Fish House Punch served in?

A rocks glass. The wide mouth puts the aroma of a citrus twist right under your nose, and the heavy base survives muddling and stirring in the glass.

Is a Fish House Punch shaken or stirred?

Stirred. It contains only spirits and modifiers, so stirring chills and dilutes it while keeping it clear and silky.

How strong is a Fish House Punch?

About 13% ABV after dilution, or roughly 1.3 US standard drinks (18 g of alcohol) per serve.

How many calories are in a Fish House Punch?

Roughly 191 kcal per drink, most of it from alcohol and sugar.

Can I make a Fish House Punch without aged rum?

Yes. Dark Rum is the closest substitute, though the drink will taste different.

If You Like the Fish House Punch